Ukraine and Girard

Serhii Plokhy On Ukraine and Russia

Sophie Roell | Five Books | 24th February

Discussion of the Russia-Ukraine conflict and its historical roots. "What we see is the process of disintegration of one of the last world empires ... The Bolsheviks held [the Russian Empire] together, but it still fell apart in 1991, almost overnight. Everyone was surprised. It was a miracle that there was no major war or bloodshed. Now we realize that the war was just postponed" (3,500 words)

Why Girardians Exist

Joshua Landy | Republics Of Letters | 24th February 2012

Amusing and well-footnoted attack on the theories of René Girard, which Landy places more or less on a level with Scientology. Even if, as Girard claims, we mimic the desires of others, we would still have an near-infinity of desires from which to choose. As for Girard's theory that early humans resolved conflicts by sacrificing scapegoats, it is as "fanciful" as Freud's Oedipus Complex (14,000 words)

BROWSER CLASSIFIEDS:

Tired of slogging through jargon-filled global affairs news? Bored by dry, esoteric geopolitical analysis? Us too. Get the <5min daily briefing designed by former diplomats to help you enjoy understanding your world again. Sign up for free at internationalintrigue.io

Reach 60k+ smart, curious readers every day: Advertise in the Browser

Join the world's favourite curation newsletter: